Services

Supporting aviation OEMs in the development or procurement & integration of type-certifiable Li-Ion energy storage, power distribution and electric propulsion systems

Supporting component and manufacturers and system developers in the development, qualification and certification of their products for electrification applications in the aviation industry

Supporting the development of automotive and industrial battery systems with challenging performance, safety and weight requirements

  • Identification of right cell / battery system for vehicle / platform and vice versa
  • Supplier evaluation and selection
  • Make-or-buy decision support
  • IP & patent research and analysis
  • Reverse engineering
  • Competitive landscape analysis, market reports, trends, and evaluations
  • Cell performance & format evaluation and selection criteria guidance
  • Next-gen cell roadmap, feasibility, and performance assessment
  • Business case assessment & SWOT analysis
  • Brainstorming & sparring partner
  • Development or evaluation of conceptual design for technical proposal
  • Support in the estimation of development and certification effort
  • Operational concept analysis incl. ground support systems
  • Definition or impact assessment of high-level technical requirements in proposal
  • Definition or impact assessment of required standards and guidelines
  • Evaluation of change requests impact on schedule and cost
  • Blank-sheet concept development to cover specific performance, safety, and operational requirements
  • Functional breakdown of propulsion system and allocation of functions to components incl. BMS
  • E/E architecture proposals covering BMS, power path in battery pack and power distribution on vehicle level
  • Cell, pack & system physical layout proposals incl. component selection considering safety, weight, and space constraints
  • Electrothermal performance modeling and simulation from cell to system level
  • Proof-of-concept test definition and assessment
  • Support the definition of design and development plans based on ARP 4754, DO-178, DO-254
  • Support in creation or review of Preliminary System Safety Assessments
  • Specialization in fire protection methods, lightweighting and cylindrical cells
  • Requirements elicitation, analysis, review and modeling
  • Independent requirements validation (necessity, consistency, rationale, traceability etc.)
  • Functional, performance and certification requirements definition
  • Decomposition of top / vehicle level, safety and certification requirements to propulsion system, battery system or component level requirements
  • Assumption management and validation
  • Conflict identification and resolution
  • Impact analysis of change requests
  • Assessment and improvement of cost, weight, safety & reliability for system under development, or for existing battery systems
  • Tradeoff analysis, engineering tests, trade studies
  • Detailed design support for battery packs considering electrical, mechanical, thermal requirements and interdependencies
  • Technical supplier management
  • Manufacturability evaluation and optimization
  • Desing, performance and operational limitations evaluation and documentation
  • Development or review of Design Description Documents
  • Critical Design Review
  • Definition and parametrization of SOC, SOH, SOE, SOP, balancing BMS algorithms
  • Module & pack assembly process definition support and review
  • Risk assessment & PFMEA
  • Incoming, inline and end of line inspections definition
  • Acceptance Test Procedure development
  • First Article Inspection
  • Verification of vehicle integration concept
  • Delta analysis of existing equipment qualification for new application / installation
  • Ground support systems integration
  • Definition or review of test procedures, test setups and pass/fail criteria
  • Proof-of-concept, development, engineering, qualification, verification/certification tests
  • Test lab selection and coordination
  • Cell, module, pack, battery system and propulsion system level testing
  • Electrical, mechanical, thermal and abuse tests
  • Test equipment evaluation and selection support
  • Data analysis and evaluation of test results, creation or review of test reports
  • Assessment of failed tests, troubleshooting and design improvement suggestions
  • DO-160, DO-311A, ECE R100, UN38.3, SAE, ASTM, EUROCAE, UL etc. standards
  • Certification Plan and Means of Compliance definition for SC-VTOL, SC-E19, CS-23/25/27/29 for battery and electric propulsion systems
  • Alignment with applicable EASA Panels 5 & 19
  • Formal Type Design Data review and approval
  • Approval of test plans & verification of conformity of test articles and test setups
  • Classification and approval of changes, production deviations and non-conformities
  • Guidance and training of design and test engineers regarding certification relevant activities
  • Independent verification of documents related to approval of Flight Conditions
  • Support in obtaining and maintaining Design Organization Approval
  • Support during development review gates (PDR, CDR, TRR, FRR)

Expertise from Cell to Propulsion System level

Services Overview

Why electrivertic

Hands-on battery development experience for various industries

Deep technical knowhow in most disciplines needed for battery deveopment

Proven track record of successful leadership of challenging projects

Focus on problem solving, efficiency, innovation

Facts are friends

Get in touch


Let's discuss how I can support your projects

Case Study

eVTOL battery development

Technical leadership and responsibility for the in-house development of the first EASA-certifiable aviation propulsion battery system for SC-VTOL category “enhanced” from blank slate up to SOP

Cell selection

Main challenges: Find an optimal solution to the multilemma: Energy density vs. power density vs. availability vs. safety vs. aviation qualification, to comply with product and certification requirements

Role: Technical assessment & selection responsibility

E/E architecture

Main challenges: Design HV electrical system layout with redundand battery packs, power distribution and BMS, incl. component selection, so as to maximize power provision safety & reliability (FDAL A, higher than ASIL-D) while minimizing weight and development effort

Role: Concept developemnt & technical leadership

Tradeoff studies

Main challenges: Assess impact of battery-side and/or aircraft-side modifications on aircraft performance and regulatory/product requirements compliance by developing battery models and integrating with aircraft models

Role: Model development & analysis responsibility

Interface management

Main challenges: Coordinate electrical, electronic, physical and thermal interfaces of battery system with aircraft structure and avionics systems and develop battery system HMI (cautions and warnings, remaining energy, range and time pilot indications)

Role: Concept development & technical responsibility

Thermal Runaway - Fire safety

Main challenges: Find agreement with certification authorities on safety targets (much higher requirements than in automotive), develop and verify concepts to meet requirements while minimizing weight.

Role: Detailed development & technical responsibility

Thermal management

Main challenges: Develop a thermal management system for the swappable battery packs with minimal weight, complexity, development and certification effort.

Role: Concept development incl. simulation & technical leadership

Weight

Main challenges: Find materials and structural concepts for the battery pack housings and aircraft integration that are able to withstand high vibration, crash and thermal (fire) loads with minimal weight

Role: Concept development & technical responsibility

Testing

Main challenges: Define development and certification verification testing methods and strategy, and deploy testing infrastructure for electrical, mechanical, thermal and abuse testing from cell to system level

Role: Technical leadership & responsibility

Manufacturing

Main challenges: Prepare make vs. buy decision for pack manufacturing and define production concept & key processes, production equipment requirements, and incoming / inline / end of line inspection methods

Role: Technical leadership

Certification

Main challenges: Work with authorities and standards bodies to finalize unclear / incomplete certification requirements for aviation electric propulsion systems and ensure full implementation by the development team, adhering to aviation development processes

Role: Leadership & responsibility (CVE)

Additional project examples

EV

Development of highest power density modular battery system for supercar

  • Develop proof-of-concept for highest volumetric power density chassis-integrated 800V battery modules with cylindrical cells
  • Role: Project manager & technical lead
  • Work with cell manufacturer to qualify cell for usage outside the nominal operating range to cover power peaks
  • Create a unique lighweight top+bottom cooling plate solution for highly efficient cooling from cell poles
  • Design single battery module for horizontal or vertical stacking
  • Develop novel copper-based laser-welded cell connection scheme to handle high currents and double as thermal interface to cooling plates
  • Verified cylindrical pack level specs:
  • 156 Wh/kg – 295 Wh/l
    1500 W/kg – 2800 W/l continuous
    2600 W/kg – 4850 W/l for 30s

BMS

Development of functionally safe BMS for industrial and off-road applications

  • Develop a functionally safe BMS without safety-critical software
  • Optimize SOx and balancing functions
  • Role: Technical expert & simulation tool developer
  • Separate safety functions in simple HW from “comfort” functions in SW
  • Define required functionality in “comfort” and “safety” subsystems
  • Select components for HW-based safety monitoring and actuation, from ASICs to low-level transistor and gate logic
  • Perform design reviews, safety assessments, FMEAs, troubleshooting / RCAs
  • Develop flexible cell-level battery simulation tool in MATLAB to investigate and optimize SOx and balancing algorithms

Battery production

Introduction of laser welding for the production of cylindrical cell packs

  • Assess, verify and deploy laser welding for cylindrical battery pack production
  • Role: Project manager
  • Evaluate laser welding, wire bonding and laser bonding as alternatives to resistance welding and prepare management decision
  • Work with equipment manufacturer and pack customers to define requirements for laser welding equipment
  • Run and evaluate trials
  • Support SOP

Frequently Asked Questions

Primary focus in aviation is on safety and reliability:

  • Fail-operational instead of fail-safe.
  • Widespread usage of redundancy and dissimilarity in system and component design.

Continued safe flight and landing (CSFL) at designated landing sites after any kind of failure has to be ensured. High priority on safe management of fire with high safety margins:

  • Assumption of single-cell failure and demonstration of non-propagation under worst-case TR triggering condiftions
  • Assumption of simultaneous multi-cell failure (20% of cells in a pack) and demonstration of safe management of resulting fire until landing.
  • Demonstration of no fire after crash (drop from 15.2m – 62km/h impact on concrete surface).

Emphasis on battery weight instead of battery volume:

  • Gravimetric energy density more important than volumetric.
  • Higher importance of vehicle-level optimization instead of system-level optimization.

There are not yet fully finalized requirements for the certification of aviation propulsion batteries:

  • SC-VTOL, the Special Condition under which eVTOLs can receive a Type Certificate by EASA, defines high-level objectives (the “What”, e.g. “no single failure catastrophic”, “safe management of fire”, “loss of life less than once every 1e9 flight hours”), but not what to do to achieve them or how they can be demonstrated to the authorities (the “How”, i.e. the Acceptable Means of Compliance (AMC)).
  • Means of Compliance (MOC) are being currently developed and published by both regulators (EASA) and industry standardization bodies (EUROCAE, SAE) to answer this “How”.

Not everyone can develop and certify a battery system for use in aviation. Even if the final product passes all tests requested by the regulators for certification, it can not be used in a type certified aircraft unless:

  • The technical experts of the certifying authority are supervising the development from the early stages of the project (Level of Involvement LOI).
  • The certifying authority ensures that the company designing the system is following the required aviation development processes (Design Organization Approval DOA).
  • The certifying authority ensures that the company manufacturing the system is following the required aviation manufacturing processes (Production Organization Approval POA).

These are two streams that run in parallel:

  • Product development
  • Certification

The company should hold a Design Organization Approval from the corresponding certification authority, ensuring that the required quality and development assurance processes are in place.

Product developement

  • The product development process follows in general the V model as described in the standard ARP 4754A: Guidelines for Development of Civil Aircraft and Systems
  • In order for the products to be able to be certified, their development has to follow certains standards:
  • Hardware and software developemnt is done according to RTCA DO-178C: Software Considerations in Airborne Systems and Equipment Certification and RTCA DO-254: Design Assurance Guidance for Airborne Electronic Hardware
  • Safety assessment is covered by ARP 4761: Guidelines and Methods for Conducting the Safety Assessment Process on Civil Airborne Systems and Equipment
  • Battery development and testing guidelines are defined in RTCA DO-311A: Minimum Operational Performance Standards for Rechargeable Lithium Batteries and Battery Systems, RTCA DO-160G: Environmental Conditions and Test Procedures for Airborne Equipment and various EUROCAE, SAE and ASTM standards currently under development
  • Reviews like System Definition Review SDR, Preliminary Design Review PDR, Critical Design Review CDR, Test Readiness Review TRR and Flight Readiness Review FRR provide development gates.

Certification

  • First, the certification basis has to be established, i.e. which high-level requirements the aircraft must fulfill, depending on it’s type. There is e.g. SC-VTOL for eVTOLs, CS-27/29 for helicopters or CS-23/25 for airplanes. SC-E19 for electric propulsion systems is also applicable in addition in the case of electric or hybrid aircraft. The applicant must find an agreement with the certification authorities about which of these requirements are applicable for their specific program.
  • Based on this and the aircraft/systems design and specifications, the OEM creates Certification Plans (CP) for the aircraft and its systems, that describe how it will be shown that the systems fulfill each applicable certification requirement (Means of Compliance, i.e. which documents will be produced, which tests or analyses will be performed etc.), and what Level of Involvement the certification authorities will have in the compliance demonstration activities. The CP must be submitted and approved by the authorities.
  • During the development of the components and systems, design descriptions, analysis documents, safety assessments, drawings, engineering tests etc. are created and properly documented. These are checked during the development review gates and partially submitted as compliance documents, as defined in the CP.
  • When components or systems of the final design are ready, they are tested according to the CP. The certification authorities can witness any certification relevant test they wish and review any of the component’s development artifacts.
  • After all test and development documentation, analysis reports etc. as defined in the CP have been collected, they are submitted to the authorities for approval and the Type Certificate is issued.
Production
  •  The Type Design Data that describes all aircrat components and their manufacturing and assembly processes are transferred to a Production Organization, which is a company allowed by the authorities to produce aircraft or aircraft components following the applicable quality management systems and ensuring that the aircraft or components produced during the lifetime of the program have the exact same properties as the aircraft or components that were tested during the certification process.
The above is a very simplified overview of the development and certification process, for persons outside the aviation industry. They are based on the European (EASA) rules, but the process in USA (FAA) is very similar.

Contact

Call

+49 1515 424 7781

Meet

Grötzinger Str. 42
76227 Karlsruhe
Germany